Establishing a chain of custody and preserving evidence for testing. Feb 24, 2012 chain of custody principals are so important to establishing the reliability of evidence that they were incorporated into the mlbs joint drug prevention and treatment program the policy under. After days of putting the dna evidence under a shadow, the jury couldnt convict beyond a reasonable doubt and simpson was acquitted. Chain of custody coc, in legal contexts, is the chronological documentation or paper trail that. Zinnikas, fbinyojttf chainofcustody is the ability to give an accurate accounting in a court of law as to the manner in which evidence was acquired, maintained, transported, examined, etc. It establishes the proof that the items of evidence collected at the crime scene is the same evidence that is being presented in a court of law. Judges in bench trials and jurors in jury trials are obligated to decide cases on the evidence that is presented to them in court.
Denim, as a crimesolving tool, has holes old school technique helps identify victim in 50yearold killing. Any movement of the evidence within the laboratory must be documented to maintain this chain of custody. The chain of custody is the roadmap for the evidence gathered in a criminal case. Calling the evidence chain of custody evidence, ironically offers a clue to why this might not be so. There is a lesser chance of contamination with fewer handlers and a shorter chain of custody. West publishing, volume 32, chapter 21, section 1034,honorable leonard arnold, j. Dna evidence places malone at the bloodsoaked murder scene of his estranged. Practice, criminal procedure by honorable leonard arnoldretired, j.
The term chain of custody refers to the process of maintaining and documenting the handling of evidence. Chain of custody principals are so important to establishing the reliability of evidence that they were incorporated into the mlbs joint drug prevention and treatment program the policy under. A typical chain of custody form will describe the evidence and detail the location and conditions under which the evidence was collected. By following the chain of custody, you can see where an item of evidence has been from the moment it was collected to the time it is offered as evidence in a criminal trial. If by chance that there was a contamination, it can be traced to a specific point in the chain of custody. The chain of custody is the means of verifying the authenticity and legal integrity of trace or sample evidence by establishing where the evidence has been and who handled it prior to the trial. Maintaining a chain of custody is essential for the forensic scientist that is. Evidence needs to follow a chain of custody, or the processes for documenting, collecting, and protecting evidence. In criminal trials, the prosecution must typically prove that all evidence was handled according to a properly documented and unbroken chain of custody. Dna samples can be obtained from the tiniest evidence. The sample collector, verifies all tested parties identification, takes photos and. A break in the chain of custody may fatally undermine the reliability of the evidence and the defense lawyer may file a motion to suppress that evidence. In other words, if you break the chain, you dont have any authoritative way of linking. In chain of custody, harold levy describes the plight of michael malone, a cardiologist turned highpowered lawyer.
Continuity evidence in criminal cases a somewhat defence. Chain of custody legal definition of chain of custody. You are defense counsel in a case with dna evidence or where the absence of dna evidence may raise factual or legal issues. Golden state killer suspect offers to plead guilty. According to ryder 2017, the rules of evidence are the rules investigators must follow. Important files, dna, photographs, and other information can corroborate a suspects testimony or disprove a defendants argument so the jury and other authorities involved can make a confident decision. A proper chain of custody requires three types of testimony. What every investigator and evidence technician should know about dna evidence. In order for the dna test outcomes to be recognized for usage in us courtrooms, not only are test results required to exceed cpi 100 for inclusions and 0 or exclusions genex results are at least x more accurate than what is required by cour, but the strict chain of custody maintained throughout sample collections and analysis at the laboratory is also of consideration. He is the prime targetin a farreaching conspiracy of merciless revenge and police coverup. Every person who handles evidence must be accounted for and recorded as a link in an unbroken chain of custody, from crime scene to courtroom.
May 15, 20 it is called chain of custody because during the sample collection process and testing process, the dna samples follow a strict and documented chain of custody. Patc articles dna testing timeline public agency training council. Collection techniques, preservation, packaging, transportation, storage and creation of the inventory list are all part of the process used in establishing the chain of custody. The movement and location of physical evidence from the time it is obtained until the time it is presented in court. Dna evidence, when properly collected and analyzed, and when relevant to an alleged crime, can have extraordinary value in the adjudication of a criminal case. Chain of custody describes a process as testified to by an. Chain of custody provides a unique identifier so it cannot be confused with any other evidence item. It is also used in parentage testing, 2 to establish immigration eligibility, 3 and in genealogical and medical research. It is called chain of custody because during the sample collection process and testing process, the dna samples follow a strict and documented chain of custody.
The only dna laboratory directed by a medical doctor, with years of experience testifying in u. Chainofcustody describes a process as testified to by an. Chain of custody a process of documentation that shows that the evidence was under strict control at all times and no unauthorized individuals were given the oppertunity to corrupt the evidence. This notebook is designed to help defense attorneys understand. The first type of evidence and usually the most obvious is physical evidence. The las vegas chain of custody refers to the foundation that the prosecution needs in order to establish that certain types of evidence can be admitted at trial. Without a continuous record showing that evidence has been kept safe and secure from the crime scene to the lab and ultimately the courtroom, evidence may be rendered inadmissible in court. Proper tagging and labeling of evidence for later identification. The collection and preservation of dna evidence must be done by the book.
Doubt about the chainofcustody comprised an important component of the defense case in the o simpson murder trial with police being accused of planting key evidence linking him to the victims and the crime scene box 9. Forensic analyst jack analyses the iron rod at the laboratory and collects. Origin where was evidence when it was collected custodial agency. This book is distributed under the terms of the creative commons. Chain of custody chain of evidence statpearls ncbi bookshelf. He is the prime targetin a farreaching conspiracy of. Chain of custody refers to the chronological documentation or paper trail, showing the seizure, custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of evidence, physical or electronic. Principles of forensic dna for officers of the court. Chain of custody definition, examples, cases, processes.
For the evidence to be of use in a trial, it must make the journey from crime scene to court in a validated and secure manner so that all involved can be assured that it has not been contaminated and that the evidence is relevant to the crime investigation. How forensics experts protect the chain of custody dummies. As a forensic dna analyst, i have often been asked why dna analysis takes so long. How to challenge chain of custody issues in las vegas. The chain of custody is the most critical process of evidence documentation. Chain of custody in a criminal case legal guides avvo. The documentation of evidence is key for maintaining a chain of custody. Dna paternity testing chain of custody genex diagnostics. This chapter provides an overview of how dna evidence might be used in the. Evidence found at the scene of a crime must eventually be presented and questioned in the courtroom. The ultimate goal of evidence collection is to prevent loss, damage and contamination while maintaining a proper chain of custody. The sample collector, verifies all tested parties identification, takes photos and has each tested party attest to their identity.
The procedure for establishing chain of custody starts with the crime scene. Although it was documented in his notes by detective mark fuhrman, one of the first. The chain of custody is defined as the witnessed, written record of all of the individuals who maintained unbroken control over the items of evidence. Improving chain of custody in forensic investigation of. In order to track chain of custody, a paper trail is maintained so that personnel in possession of the evidence at different times can be identified. Nov 16, 2015 all articles why is chain of custody tracking important. Although this is a common plot in legal thrillers, levy does a good job of raising this novel a few notches above the ordinary. The chain of custody form ccf or coc is used to record all changes in the seizure, custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of physical and electronic evidence. Of particular importance in criminal cases, the concept is also applied in civil litigationand sometimes more broadly in drug. Mar 09, 2019 the term chain of custody refers to the process of maintaining and documenting the handling of evidence. For additional ebooks and books, please search the book catalog. Dna profiling is a forensic technique in criminal investigations, comparing criminal suspects profiles to dna evidence so as to assess the likelihood of their involvement in the crime. Doubt about the chain of custody comprised an important component of the defense case in the o simpson murder trial with police being accused of planting key evidence linking him to the victims and the crime scene box 9.
Zinnikas, fbinyojttf chain of custody is the ability to give an accurate accounting in a court of law as to the manner in which evidence was acquired, maintained, transported, examined, etc. All articles why is chain of custody tracking important. Dna profiling also called dna fingerprinting is the process of determining an individuals dna characteristics. Maintaining the chain of custody evidence handling in. Dna analysis intended to identify a species, rather than an individual, is called dna barcoding dna profiling is a forensic technique in criminal investigations, comparing criminal suspects profiles to dna evidence so as to assess the likelihood of their involvement. The chain of custody is a crucial part of the evidencehandling procedure that can make or break any case.
Evidence acquired according to a search warrant will mandate digital forensics professionals to follow the chain of custody from that point forward. When the analyst takes custody of evidence and performs visual examinations, critical information. When a defendants attorney argues the police failed to maintain proper control over collected evidence, the allegation is that a violation of the chain of custody has occurred. Evidence collection from the beginning, there were issues involving evidence collection. Evidence management can make or break a court case. These key pieces of evidence are relevant to the facts of the case and can determine whether a defendant is found guilty or not. Dna evidence places malone at the bloodsoaked murder scene of his estranged wife, a deputy da who was suing him for custody of their only child. Previous one was multi county book with pages 3334 pulled out of it. Neither judges nor jurors may conduct their own investigations into the. Jan 01, 2019 chain of custody is the movement and location of physical evidence from the time it is obtained until the time it is presented in court, and is used to prove the integrity of a piece of evidence.
Each book is made up of 100 test pages printed in triplicate. Mar, 2019 chain of custody is a legal term referring to the order and manner in which physical or electronic evidence in criminal and civil investigations has been handled. It also includes spaces for recording drug, alcohol and urine test results. In r v mcnair unreported, supreme court of victoria court of appeal, 8 may 1997, the victorian court of appeal doubted a direction, given in a dna case, that continuity in the circumstances of that case, had to be proved beyond. Because evidence can be used in court to convict persons of crimes it must be handled in a scrupulously careful manner to avoid later allegations of tampering or misconduct which. If police cant account for a piece of evidence at some point between collection at the crime scene and presentation at trialthe defense could say the evidence has been compromised. Chain of custody typically refers to the foundation the prosecution needs to establish for certain types of exhibits to be admitted into evidence. It is a must to assure the court of law that the evidence is authentic, i. The chain of custody is a requirement to establish the evidentiary value of the evidence, steiker said. Maintaining the chain of custody involves preserving the integrity of evidence by documenting its possession from the moment of collection until the moment it is introduced in court.
It involves keeping a detailed log showing who collected, handled, transferred, or analyzed evidence during an investigation. An important bloody fingerprint located on the gateway at nicole browns house was not properly collected and entered into the chain of custody when it was first located. Chain of custody coc, in legal contexts, is the chronological documentation or paper trail that records the sequence of custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of physical or electronic evidence. The test for the admissibility of novel scientific evidence enunciated in frye v. Chain of custody legal dna test chain of custody refers to the chain of procedures carried out to ensure the identity of the dna samples being tested. If you are offcampus, use your library number to access the online resources. The chain of custody of the evidence has not been corrupted. Chain of custody by harry levy 1999, paperback for sale.
Jun 28, 2016 after days of putting the dna evidence under a shadow, the jury couldnt convict beyond a reasonable doubt and simpson was acquitted. May 15, 2012 the chain of custody is the roadmap for the evidence gathered in a criminal case. Chain of custody chain of evidence statpearls ncbi. Digital forensics court testimony and the chain of custody. But improper dna evidence collection could destroy your case. How improper dna evidence collection can compromise your case. Malone is accused of murder and the evidence against him is convincing. But malone fears he is more than the prime suspect. Anything less will invalidate what might otherwise be very persuasive dna evidence. Mar 01, 2002 the chain of custody is a requirement to establish the evidentiary value of the evidence, steiker said. Introduction to forensic science chain of custody crj 3410. Exhibits are tangible objects that are relevant to the facts of a casefor example.
110 133 1482 522 682 1167 298 135 760 60 130 320 890 726 673 265 1415 1358 60 197 1416 1309 53 805 843 217 306 1254 492 1131